Protection of doctors from unfounded lawsuits

An increasing number of patient lawsuits against doctors raises the question: how can healthcare professionals protect themselves against unfounded claims? The legal protection of doctors safeguards not only the individual, but also trust in the entire healthcare system of the Republic of Serbia.

Introduction

Modern medicine enables increasingly precise diagnostics and treatment, while also increasing the risk of complications that do not necessarily have to be the result of a mistake. Case law shows an increase in both civil and criminal proceedings against doctors, even though every complication is not proof of incompetence.

The legal system recognises the importance of the medical profession and protects doctors who act conscientiously. In the Republic of Serbia, a distinction is made between objective responsibility of the medical institution and subjective responsibility of the doctor, and the law provides clear mechanisms of protection against baseless lawsuits.

When the doctor is and when he is not responsible

According to to the Law on Obligations, the doctor's liability exists only if the following conditions are met:

• There is a doctor's guilt for acting contrary to the rules of the profession;
• Such treatment caused harm to the patient;
• There is a causal link between the action and the harmful consequence.

If a doctor acts conscientiously, according to the rules of the profession and in accordance with treatment standards, they cannot be held responsible for complications that are the result of the nature of the disease, an unpredictable bodily reaction or an unavoidable medical risk.

The role of medical expertise

Medical expertise represents a key piece of evidence in proceedings relating to medical liability. The court engages a medical expert in the appropriate branch of medicine, who determines:

• did the doctor follow the rules of the profession,
• whether a mistake was made during the diagnosis, therapy or monitoring of the patient,
• whether there is a cause-and-effect relationship between the doctor's actions and the damage.

If no wrongdoing is proven, the court shall dismiss the claim. This provides doctors who act conscientiously with real and effective legal protection.

Legal mechanisms for the protection of doctors

During the procedure, the doctor can prove his conscientiousness and professionalism through the following:

• Proper management of medical documentation - proof of correct behavior;
• Informed consent of the patient - duty to inform about risks and obtain consent;
• Compliance with standards and protocols - confirmation of action in accordance with the rules of the profession.

If it is proven that the lawsuit is unfounded, the doctor has the right to reimbursement of procedural costs, and in cases of abuse of rights – also the right to counterclaim for injury to reputation and honor.

A relationship of trust between doctor and patient

The relationship between doctor and patient must be based on trust and cooperation. The patient has the right to information and adequate care, but there is no guarantee of absolute cure, as all organisms are different.

Protecting doctors from unfounded lawsuits safeguards the morale, stability and security of healthcare professionals, while also helping to strengthen trust in the healthcare system.

Conclusion

The Republic of Serbia has a clear legal framework that protects doctors from groundless lawsuits, encompassing civil, criminal and disciplinary mechanisms. The task of a lawyer is to provide doctors with expert and legal support in proving conscientious conduct.

The legal system strives to strike a balance between patient protection and the rights of conscientious doctors – because only such trust sustains healthcare and justice.

You can also read the blog here link.

Lawyer

The patient develops an infection after routine surgery even though all aseptic protocols were followed. In that case, the physician is not liable, as they did not breach professional rules. Practical example: Agreement for lifetime support Dog bite - damages claim